Sunday, September 9, 2012

A Visit to the Zoo



Recently I visited a zoo. By the word 'zoo' I mean its usage in a popular and technical sense. So I visited the zoo! Caged animals appeared morose and sulky to the human eyes in general. I overheard some of my own species ruing at the plight of the poor creatures. Some expressed disgust mentioning utter depravity of the mankind that has sunk to such a level that it derives amusement at other's misery. Schadenfreude! And some were playing crude pranks (I lack better words!) with the animals - throwing stones, sticking them through the fencing, snapping the tails etc. Still some were enough moved to offer human eatables to the animals, without caring about its digestive implications. I think they all - if we disregard the pranksters to an extent - were committing a grave error called anthropomorphism i.e. applying human emotions and behavior to judge a fellow animal. I found it quite absurd though in no way I meant to demean my fellow animals. On the contrary I glossed over the possibilities of these beings at higher spiritual pedestal and thus more evolved. My mind too sprouted some reasons in support. I reflected about our own existence and our relation to the society. The way we have social and personal chains all around us, the way we are forced to confine ourselves to a place or restricted from moving to an another place, the way we do our diurnal confined foraging job that ensures food at fixed periods of a day blurred some deeply etched boundaries. All these ramblings, like a deft artist began to paint the picture in my perception. I could see two zoos existing at the same time. As if both saw each other and some subtle conversations transpired between them making one amused and the other - allow me my share of anthropomorphism - crestfallen, sad and at best apathetically withdrawn. My analysis had profuse measures of anthropomorphism. Therefore, I had to confine these vagrant thoughts in the deep cellar of my mind. My thought train was derailed when a boisterous ranting came knocking at my doors of perception. It was a young man bemoaning the 'misfortune' of the caged lion. His lofty oratory on freedom was cut short when something resembling a mobile phone hanging in chains around his neck began to ring. With a marked agility he received the call. The call made him docile and submissive. All his noisy rhetoric evaporated. He had a brief fawning conversation interspersed with many 'sirs' in between. The residual uproarious way of talking surfaced once again when he asked the other guys accompanying him to leave. He added - "Cancel the show! We may have to work overtime tonight and appraisal too is at hand". With these last audible words I saw them leaving in a hurried fashion. At this point of time the lion too displayed his eloquence. It was just a routine roar or a dig at the other man's freedom, it was hard to discern. I too started to leave reflecting on the difference between confined freedom and free confinement. Again it was hard to discern.

11 comments:

  1. A very deep thought portrayed effortlessly. Brother you see the world very minutely. Keep writing.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Beautiful comparison of the so called freedom of humans with the bondage of animals. Animals are held captive by humans but humans are held captive by their own thoughts and decisions. Appreciate your portrayal. :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Glad you appreciated it :)
      Other thing I wanted to say about the limitations of human mind to capture animal behavior from a perspective independent of human emotion. As J M Coetzee said it has been greatest failure of our literature so far, that is why he feels next level of literary revolution depends on the fact that how best we are able to capture these creature without being prejudiced to our own thinking and emotion. He says when you read black beauty, you don't read about the horse but about a human who is transformed into a horse :)

      Delete
    2. This comment has been removed by the author.

      Delete
    3. You have conveyed that aspect of your thoughts very clearly as well and I agree with what you are saying.
      However, I wonder whether we will really be able to shun human emotions and think about the way animals think? No matter how we try to do that, won't our process of thinking always be dominated by human emotions - consciously or unconsciously?

      Delete
    4. Yes brother completely agree with you. This anthropocentrism of which anthropomorphism is just an off shoot has plagued many thinkers earlier too. We can only say 'what it is not' instead of 'what it is'. That would be the most honest assessment but then anthropomorphism cannot be completely ruled out either :)
      These revelations put an individual in a very difficult stage of learning when you only learn to reject without being consoled by some moments of truth, but then truth by its very nature is elusive :)

      Delete
  3. Your post reminded me of how well Nilanjana Roy's new book The Wildings (http://bit.ly/RwgsWq) has been written. The book is about a bunch of cats of Nizamuddin and tells a powerful story. It is evocatively written without being anthropomorphistic and a highly enjoyable read.
    Look forward to reading more of you bhai

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanx brother for your book recommendation and encouraging words. The Wildings seems to be highly promising in its plot. Will definitely be my next read :)

      Delete
  4. a vivid expression of bafflement lucidly written. this is the first article of yours that i read. i appreciate its originality and empathise with you as you express a basic predicament that we humans find ourselves in. a realisation of our own primitivity and ferality is indeed unsettling. look forward to reading more of you sir

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. That is something we need to come to term with in order to realize greater truths about ourselves. Even more lucidly summarized :)

      Delete